PDA

View Full Version : Malaysia's illegal worker boondoggle


SunWuKong
08-20-2004, 09:51 AM
Malaysia's illegal worker boondoggle
By Ioannis Gatsiounis

KUALA LUMPUR - Every few years it seems the Malaysian government rallies to send home the million-plus foreigners working illegally in the plantation, construction and other manual labor sectors. The last such instance was in 2002, when some 500,000 Indonesians were deported, under the threat of lashings with the rattan and stiff jail sentences. What happened next, though, has become symptomatic of these campaigns. Malaysia made bad blood with its neighbors, raised eyebrows in the international community, spread xenophobia among its own, and now finds itself home to more illegal migrants than before the "crackdown".

Indeed, these workers - from various Asian countries, but mostly from Indonesia - are more conspicuous than any time since the last flood of them started entering Malaysia in the late 1970s; the total number of immigrant workers is estimated to have increased five-fold since then, to more than 2 million. Once resigned mostly to remote plantations, their faces shrouded anonymously in towels, now some run food stands at night markets, sell durians by the roadside and wait tables. Whole neighborhoods have become theirs.

The government has taken notice and last month said it would start large-scale deportations after September 20, the day of Indonesia's presidential election. On Wednesday, however, Malaysia announced it would wait until January, to address "technical constraints".

Regardless of when the action actually transpires, the question is, will the net effect be different this time? And what are the social and economic implications?


more... (http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Southeast_Asia/FH20Ae03.html)

AliBabaIncorporated
08-20-2004, 07:39 PM
There is no labor shortage in Malaysia; there's a labor shortage at the wages the employers wish they could offer. Wake up: we're modernizing. Try raising wages.

Further, as the article glosses over, there's severe underemployment of women. This is more than just a simple gender equality problem: Until men and parents and extended families are used to the idea of women working outside the home and earning the wages to be independent, we're not going to be a normal society; we'll just keep teetering on the balance of Arabization, pushed through by rural men and students returned from the Middle East.

And even if there was a labor shortage, so what? There is no way in hell anyone is going to compete with China on cheap labor, so why flood the country with people who would vote PAS if given the chance? Don't need foreign radicalization in addition to domestic radicalization.

SunWuKong
08-20-2004, 07:44 PM
There is no labor shortage in Malaysia; there's a labor shortage at the wages the employers wish they could offer. Wake up: we're modernizing. Try raising wages.

can they all afford to raise wages? some businesses may lose their competitive edge that way.

AliBabaIncorporated
08-20-2004, 07:53 PM
In service businesses ... everyone will take the same hit in costs. And in manufacturing businesses? Like I said, we have to move up the value-added chain. There's plenty of investors who are interested in helping us move up with more capital-intensive manufacturing (like the Japanese, of whom there are many in Malaysia, and who certainly don't want all of their advanced manufacturing techniques to be bought up by China).

Besides, Malaysia already has enough income inequality, which is creating more and more resentment. Restricting the labor supply would transfer more money from the rich to the poor directly, without the government actually getting its hands on the money, unlike redistributive taxation-and-spending which ends up wasted on "pork projects" by cronies, which don't actually help the poor. Increasing the labor supply simply lets the rich and petit bourgeois have cheaper luxury apartments, restaurant meals, and maids, at the expense of the poor and of national unity. Not the kind of country I want to live in.

SunWuKong
08-20-2004, 10:48 PM
In service businesses ... everyone will take the same hit in costs.

well, not all businesses are created equal. some can survive the wage increase, and others wouldn't be able to do so. that'll put legal employees out of work.