PDA

View Full Version : Betty Ong, uncommon heroine


Faithless
01-28-2004, 08:30 AM
http://images.chicagotribune.com/media/thumbnails/photo/2004-01/11177225.jpg Betty Ong
Attendant on jet that hit 1st tower (http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/chi-0401280331jan28,1,544697.story?coll=chi-news-hed)
WASHINGTON -- The tape of Betty Ong's voice Tuesday, alive and urgent yet amazingly calm, describing how hijackers had stabbed two of her fellow flight attendants and taken over the first plane that slammed in the World Trade Center, silenced the congressional hearing room.

"The cockpit is not answering the phone. Someone's coming. Another one [passenger] got stabbed. Our first class gal's stabbed, our purser has been stabbed. We can't get inside the cockpit," Ong told an American Airlines reservations specialist in a call from the rear phone aboard doomed Flight 11.

For the first time in two days of testimony from more than two dozen officials, members of the commission investigating the Sept. 11 attacks had nothing to say.

Ong's voice, captured on tape, broke only when the aircraft suddenly plunged at the hands of inexperienced pilots who had taken over the cockpit. The tape of her call offered some of the first insight and an all-too-real account of what was happening aboard the four hijacked airplanes on the morning of Sept. 11, 2001, and lasted until her plane flew with explosive force into a Trade Center tower.

While her conversation was the most dramatic new revelation at the hearing, 9/11 commission investigators also released a nine-page report Tuesday that said the hijackers probably sprayed Mace around the cockpit area on all four flights, apparently to keep passengers away, and that they persuaded passengers to sit quietly on at least one of the flights by announcing over the intercom that there was a bomb on board.

Investigators believe the hijackers also may have used autopilot and a GPS global positioning system to target the Trade Center and the Pentagon. The report said the flight data recorder found buried in the rubble of the Pentagon indicated the pilot "had input autopilot instructions for a route to Reagan National Airport."

On Ong's flight, the hijackers appeared to have killed at least one passenger, and possibly two, before taking over the aircraft.

The tape recording picks up midsentence after an unidentified--and somewhat impatient--reservations specialist had answered the phone.

"The cockpit's not answering the phone," Ong tells the man. "Somebody's been stabbed in business class, and, um, I think there's Mace and we can't breathe and I don't know, I think we're getting hijacked."

The man replies, "What seat are you in?" apparently unaware that Ong is a flight attendant.

"Ma'am, are you there?"

"Yes," Ong says, who was having trouble hearing the man.

"What seat are you in?" the man asks, and then again forcefully, "Ma'am, what seat are you in?"

We're bound "for Boston, we're up in the air. The cockpit is not answering the phone," Ong says urgently.

The man replies, "What seat are you in?"

After a pause, Ong says, "I'm in my jump seat right now."

At that point the man seems to realize she is a flight attendant. He pauses and then asks, "What is your name?"

"OK, my name is Betty Ong. I'm an employee on Flight 11. The cockpit is not answering their phone. There is somebody stabbed in business. We can't breathe in business class. I think they have Mace or something. Somebody's coming back. Can you hold on for one second? Somebody's coming back.

"OK, our number one [flight attendant] got stabbed. Our purser is stabbed. There is no air in business class. No one can breathe. Our first class gal and our purser has been stabbed. We can't get into the cockpit. The door won't open."

After a long pause, Ong says, "Hello?"

The man responds, "Yeah. I'm taking it down, all the information. "

About a minute later the man's boss, Nydia Gonzalez, takes over the phone call.

Commission investigators on Tuesday credited Gonzalez and Ong for relaying as much information as they did, largely by way of a three-party conversation with the American Airlines emergency operations center in Dallas.

Attendant noted seat numbers

In a staff report to committee members, investigators said it was because of Ong's call that they learned about the Mace, which they said they also discovered among the belongings left in the suitcase of hijacker Mohamed Atta, who piloted Ong's plane.

Ong reported to Gonzalez that they had moved all the passengers out of first class and business class, but that many passengers in the rear of the plane didn't know what was going on.

She was also the first person to alert authorities to who the hijackers were, saying she believed there were three or four hijackers and giving authorities the men's seat numbers.

Ong's voice is absent from the second part of the tape as Gonzalez communicates with the emergency center in one ear, and listens to Ong in the other.

Ong told Gonzalez no doctors were on board to treat the flight attendants--one of whom she suspected was dead and the other who was breathing with the aid of oxygen administered by the other flight attendants.

The aircraft was flying erratically, Ong reported. Gonzalez relayed to the center that the flight attendant suspected the airlines' pilots were not flying the airplane.

Twenty-three minutes later, the line went dead.

Ong's brother and sister wiped away tears as they listened from the first row of seats in the hearing room, saying later that they felt relieved that the world would finally know that their sister, a 45-year-old from San Francisco, was a consummate professional to the end, selfless and brave.

`Our first soldiers'

Harry Ong and Cathie Ong-Herrera said the tape gives them comfort, even though they were not allowed to hear it until almost six months after the attacks, and only then after Sen. Edward Kennedy (D-Mass.) intervened. "I believe that the tape belongs to the people," Cathie Ong-Herrera said. "She and the crew did the best they could. They were our first soldiers."

Also Tuesday, staff reports presented to the commission--formally known as the Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States--showed that by 7:35 a.m. on Sept. 11, all five hijackers on American Airlines Flight 77 had been tagged by a passenger prescreening program as "a risk to aircraft safety," and four of them had set off metal detector alarms at airport checkpoints, Newsday reported.

But even after those red flags and some additional screening at Dulles International Airport in Virginia, all five were allowed to board Flight 77, which they hijacked and crashed into the Pentagon.

Commission members also asked for an extension of their May 27 deadline, saying they needed more time to review records and hear testimony. Congressional Democrats voiced their support of such a delay, but President Bush and Republican congressional leaders have said they would oppose it. Republican officials say a delay would put the release of the report too close to elections.
Such poise in the face of danger. :frown:

Chokes you up.

kasia
01-29-2004, 12:41 AM
i listened to the recording. heavy stuff. she didn't sound frantic or like she was panicking at all. she just described the situation in detail, was put on hold, and they lost her.

SunWuKong
01-29-2004, 12:58 AM
i listened to the recording. heavy stuff. she didn't sound frantic or like she was panicking at all. she just described the situation in detail, was put on hold, and they lost her.

can you link us up with the recording?

ren28
01-29-2004, 03:09 AM
I heard it on the news the other day. Pretty crazy stuff. She didn't sound too worried or anything. It made me feel kinda PO'ed all over again like I wanted to kill those bastard cowards.

ren28
01-29-2004, 03:13 AM
I looked into this trying to find the recording but instead I found this information. It's pretty messed up too.

http://www.wtclivinghistory.org/plagiarism.htm

Faithless
01-29-2004, 08:41 AM
can you link us up with the recording?
Oo, why? It brings chills. Seriously, knowing what is about to happen to the poor girl and everyone else on her plane. :frown:

kasia
01-29-2004, 09:57 AM
can you link us up with the recording?

i actually heard the recording in the news also. jensen lives in san francisco & i was up there in the beginning of the week - it was on our local news. now i'm starting to wonder if that is the *only* news station that broadcasted it. considering we're more liberal than others. was this on anyone else's local news?

kasia
01-29-2004, 10:03 AM
I looked into this trying to find the recording but instead I found this information. It's pretty messed up too.

http://www.wtclivinghistory.org/plagiarism.htm

i'm going to repost it here, jensen.

When Langewiesche writes the shocking words from American Flight 11, Flight Attendant Betty Ong—don’t be fooled. Mr. Langewiesche did not interview Craig Marquis, American Airlines employee, the named source. In fact, neither he, or the Atlantic Monthly ever talked to Craig Marquis. We know because Rhonda Roland Shearer called him earlier this fall to ask. Mr. Marquis said that he “ never heard of Langewiesche.”

Mr. Langewiesche does not reveal to the reader that he lifted the information about Betty Ong and the United 175 Flight Attendant from the Wall Street Journal (Oct. 15, 2001). Also Langwiesche never tells us that he clipped the information about Amy Sweeney, a Flight Attendant on Amerian Flight 11 from the LA Times (Sept. 20, 2001). What’s even worse, since the Wall Street Journal front page piece was an early report of what happend on 9/11, a second-hand account about Ms. Ong was incorrect. The Wall Street Journal article wrongly depicts Betty Ong as frightened and unprofessional. Later reports (see ABC’s Diane Sawyer’s piece in the Original Documents above, on right), clear up this mistake after the three first-hand accounts from the American employees (who actually spoke to Betty Ong), gave their testimony about Ms. Ong’s remarkably calm demeanor. Moreover, these three accounts are confirmed by the official voice recording of Betty’s words made available to the Ong family.

The Ong family, and the three American Airline employees with their first hand accounts of talking to Ms. Ong during the 9/11 ordeal, were not contacted by Mr. Langewiesche or Atlantic Monthly fact-checkers. The false and unfair depiction of Betty Ong, now lives on in the American Ground book, that both his publisher’s vow is:

"a piece of history that will be read 20 years from now... [William Langewiesche is] deeply honest, with a deep integrity...."
Michael Kelly, former Managing Editor, Atlantic Monthly: His Introduction of William Langewiesche at Barnes and Noble bookstore, NYC, Nov. 19, 2002. "widely acknowledged as by far the best reportage on the aftermath of September 11th"
Excerpt from Letter to John Dunne, Uniformed Fire Officers Assn. written by Jonathan Galassi, President and Publisher, Farrar Straus, as he defends William Langewiesche.

Mr.Langewiesche and his publishers, Atlantic Monthly and Farrar Straus, so far, refuse to acknowledge and correct this harmful untruth about Betty Ong’s lack of professionalism that their book is propagating. Betty Ong’s family has been writing Langewiesche to demand corrections since August 2002 to no avail (also see above Original Document file).

Mr. Langewiesche, Atlantic Monthly, Farrar Straus, obviously, did not take the proper verification steps. If they had fact-checked, Betty Ong’s family would not have this added injury of unnecessary harm to Ms. Ong’s reputation by the pen of Mr. Langewiesche, and the paper of Atlantic Monthly’s Magazine and Farrar Straus’s book.

i want to see something done about this. i wonder how they depicted her as "frightened and unprofessional." and did they assume that because she was asian? because she was a woman? and how can they refuse to acknowledge their mistake and clear dishonesty when the recording has now been released?

Betty Ong's family is demanding corrections in the book. I wonder if anybody is backing them up.

:mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad:

yoMAMA
01-29-2004, 10:21 AM
i'm going to repost it here, jensen.



i want to see something done about this. i wonder how they depicted her as "frightened and unprofessional." and did they assume that because she was asian? because she was a woman? and how can they refuse to acknowledge their mistake and clear dishonesty when the recording has now been released?

Betty Ong's family is demanding corrections in the book. I wonder if anybody is backing them up.

:mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad:

Again, I think the best thing to do is file a lawsuit on the publisher of such things.

Defamation?

moJo
01-29-2004, 10:25 AM
http://images.chicagotribune.com/media/thumbnails/photo/2004-01/11177225.jpg Betty Ong
Attendant on jet that hit 1st tower (http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/chi-0401280331jan28,1,544697.story?coll=chi-news-hed)

Such poise in the face of danger. :frown:

Chokes you up.
i did get choked up. thanks for sharing this. i remember a chinese news station profiling her a few months or a year ago.

yoMAMA
01-29-2004, 10:28 AM
She is my HERO!

[salute]

Faithless
01-29-2004, 11:05 AM
I think one of the interesting things playing-out of this is the potential use of Ong as a "poster child" of sorts for 9-11.

As much time as 9/11 needs (http://www.oregonlive.com/editorials/oregonian/index.ssf?/base/editorial/1075381151263300.xml)
T he last task of flight attendant Betty Ong, just before her airplane slammed into the World Trade Center, was to gather information, place a call and share everything she knew about the hijacking -- calmly, thoroughly and urgently.


From Our Advertiser




She needed more time. She didn't get it, as the independent bipartisan group studying the Sept. 11 attacks learned in hearings this week. She and her passengers died in a terrorist plot that involved doctored passports, misused visas, unnoticed weapons, unchecked terrorist watch lists and unheeded national warnings.

An investigation of that day should leave no question unanswered. The National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States needs ample time to conduct a full, useful analysis. On Tuesday, the Republican chairman of this group asked Congress for a two-month extension of its May deadline.

Congress should grant the extension gladly -- and ignore the Bush administration's whine that the change will interfere with the presidential race.

Let it.
...

kasia
01-30-2004, 01:10 AM
please keep us updated with any new information that you guys hear that might be related to this.

kasia
02-02-2004, 01:20 PM
a letter to her from her brother:

Dear Bee:

I don't know fully why you left us
I don't know fully when you left us
I don't know fully how you left us
But I do know that I miss you so very much

I do know that you left us doing the job you loved best
I do know you left us fighting to the very end
And I do know you did your job most heroically

Oh how I wish I could turn the clock back to make things whole again
This is so much like a dream
I never expected to write you this letter...
Let alone a letter like this for you before me

Each day I wake up waiting for you to call or I.M. me just to say "Hello"
I go over and over the moments we shared together and wish we could share even more
And now as I slowly wake up each day, I realize that I can only talk to you in my heart and know that you are here in spirit

I whisper a little "hello" when I walk by your picture each day
Bee, I will never really say goodbye to you
because you are forever in my heart and soul
Bee, I just want to say I'm so very proud of you
And I really miss you so

Your loving brother, Harry